Pundits split over Timber’s pull on Isak as VAR clears Arsenal

Image: Love Liverpool graphic

Liverpool’s 1-0 home defeat to Arsenal on Sunday was settled by Kai Havertz, but the talking point that followed fans out of Anfield was a penalty appeal that never came.

In the 21st minute Alexander Isak went down in the Arsenal area under a challenge from Jurrien Timber, with the Dutch defender appearing to hold the striker’s shirt. Referee Andy Madley played on. The video assistant referee checked the incident and decided it did not reach the threshold for a clear and obvious error, so no on-field review was recommended.

What the pundits said

The Sky Sports team could not agree, according to reports in the Evening Standard and the Mirror. Jamie Carragher told VAR to do its job. Daniel Sturridge called it clear and blatant. Ian Wright said Arsenal were glad to get away with it.

Gary Neville was less sure. He said Isak’s lack of reaction at the time was odd, and he suggested that may have helped the officials decide to let play go on.

Liverpool had a second shout when Christos Tzolis and Cody Gakpo came together in the box. That one was also waved away, and Neville said he did not think it was a penalty.

Why it matters

On another day a spot-kick would have changed the whole afternoon. Liverpool did not manage a single shot on target at home, so one decision carried more weight than usual. The loss leaves Andoni Iraola’s side nine points behind the leaders, and supporters will feel the swing in a title race that is starting to slip away.

Do not expect the debate to be settled. The Premier League’s independent key match incidents panel looks at the big calls each week. If it publishes a view on this one, we will update this story. Until then, the officials’ decision stands, and nothing Liverpool say can change the result.

For the full story of the afternoon, read our Liverpool 0-1 Arsenal match report. You can also see how Iraola lined up in our team news from Anfield.

Liverpool’s next chance to bounce back comes quickly. Check every date and TV slot in our November fixtures guide.

Part of the Love network: LoveBelfast · Love Dublin · Love Liverpool